Railways require safe, reliable power systems to support signals, points and communications infrastructure.
Trackside equipment must be protected from failure, and with thousands of miles of track to maintain, Network Rail demands maximum visibility to assess the health and condition of its infrastructure.
UK rail networks are subject to harsh operating conditions and incidents of theft, accidental damage and degradation. Finding and locating faults is challenging, currently requiring rail personnel to spend thousands of hours trackside inspecting and locating failing cable.
The major drive to get ‘boots off ballast’ is supported by earlier identification of emerging power system faults and more accurate fault location technology. This in turn gives a longer window to rectify faults and enables predictive and preventive maintenance rather than reactive maintenance, offering opportunities to deal with faults before they become critical.
More effective fault finding translates into fewer train delays and an improved customer service with reduced associated costs for train operators through fewer penalties.
Most rail signalling power supply issues (more than 80%) result from core-to-earth faults where damage or deterioration of a cable or its insulating covering will eventually lead to failure, impacting on safety and the efficient operation of rail services.
Bender’s Rail Signalling Power Monitoring systems have been the principal method of tracking and locating faults on the rail signalling power network for two decades. However, less critical emerging faults at lower intervention/insulation limits are more difficult to track and pinpoint.
Network Rail regulation NR/L3/SIGELP/50001 requires an increase in intervention windows. Faults identified at critical stages (20 kΩ or lower) require immediate intervention within 24 hours. Advanced monitoring and insulation fault location at up to 100kΩ increases intervention time, enabling fault identification within a prescribed 6-week window. More importantly, it also offers the option of dealing with the fault over a longer timescale through planned and predictive maintenance.
The new generation multi-tier RS4 Rail Signalling Power Monitoring system from Bender UK offers increased sensitivity for first fault location and remote condition monitoring of core-to-earth failure of Network Rail signalling IT power systems.
It was developed collaboratively with Network Rail (NR) in response to new standards designed to reduce maintenance, reduce infrastructure and service failures and improve staff safety by minimising trackside intervention and ‘boots on ballast’.
RS4 is compliant with Network Rail’s Insulation Monitoring and Fault Location requirements. It provides continuous monitoring of ‘live’ rail signal power systems and pinpoints the locations of cable or earth faults without the need to power down systems.
RS4 incorporates 3G/4G enabled data loggers equipped for real-time direct communication with Network Rail’s Intelligent Infrastructure. Data from the continuous monitoring is supplied in weekly reports delivered directly to Network Rail and can be supplemented with further detail and analysis to create a holistic picture of the network. .
Manual cable testing on a 5-year cycle NR/L2/SIGELP/50000 continues to be a requirement, but RS4 is a key step forward in enabling Network Rail to move from periodic testing to a real-time condition-based approach through continuous testing. .
Multi-tier core-to-earth fault location
The new RS4 system is designed to satisfy Network Rail Tier 1, 2 and 3 fault location requirements. It employs tried and trusted Bender measuring technology with increased sensitivity for improved feeder first fault location.
RS4 delivers continuous monitoring and analysis capabilities unachievable with previous technology. The lower the resistance, the more serious the fault; the limit at which faults could previously be located was 20kΩ – which indicated a fault requiring urgent attention. Higher resistance levels around 100kΩ are early warnings of cable insulation degradation but they were previously almost impossible to locate.
RS4 insulation monitoring combines with an integrated fault locating current injector, pinpointing the fault locations on miles of networked cables.
The new system also measures capacitance, voltage and frequency offering engineers a holistic picture of cable health enabling them to identify emerging problems and providing a rich data set that meets the requirements of multi-tier standard NR/L2/SIGELP/27725
How the monitoring and location-finding works
RS4 narrows the location of core-to-earth high resistance faults to specific short lengths of the power supply cable using fixed technology. This fault location can be carried out without cutting the power, while the system is online/running, and complies with the IEC 61557-9 definition of an iFLS/ fault location system.
Time Domain Reflectometry - a supplementary fault location technology sometimes confused with iFLS - is effective only on rare core-to-core short circuit or open circuit faults when a power failure has occurred and is already causing train delays.
RS4 continually monitors insulation resistance (IR) to show real-time status of the power system. When IR drops, the system records the fault, sending a test current signal into the system which is pulled to earth at the point of fault.
Bender’s EDS3090 portable earth fault location system (often referred to by rail professionals as ‘the Bender Wand’) precisely locates feeder earth faults line-side, allowing the repair process to be carried out more quickly with minimal disruption.
The handheld unit pinpoints a network earth fault to a specific cable or transformer by detecting the test signal from Bender devices and does not require the cable or transformer to be disconnected. EDS3090 simply clamps to the cable to carry out the evaluation enabling spot checks to discover whether a fault is present in addition to pinpointing faults identified in the vicinity.
RS4 can cost effectively upgrade earlier generation RS2/RS3 installations. That is an important economic consideration for Network Rail which has more than 1,000 Bender units installed across thousands of miles of track as a mainstay of its electrical rail power monitoring technology. Upgrading existing equipment
The new generation Bender system therefore offers cost-effective continuation for legacy equipment that is compatible with Network Rail’s Intelligent Infrastructure and delivers remote condition monitoring through the GSM 3G/4G enabled data loggers.
Network Rail has formally approved Bender UK’s next generation RS4 Rail Signalling Power Protection system at Tier 3 level, and testing is on track for Tier 2 and Tier 1 installations.
The Network Rail full approval certificate (PA05/04750) covers the Tier 3 version of the RS4 devices. The RS4 Tier3 PADs number on the Network Rail accepted products database is 0086/001406.
Full approval certification of RS4 units makes specification of the equipment simple for Network Rail and its partners who are committed to delivering the multiple-tier smart cable insulation monitoring and fault location that is required to reduce rail downtime and achieve the highest operational standards.
RS4 Tier 3
The Tier 3 RS4 is designed to comply with Network Rail standard NR/L2/SIGELP/27725. It offers an overall system insulation resistance level measurement that includes multiple feeder systems and signal power supplies where each feeder is fed from either a common or individual isolation transformer. Increased sensitivity improves fault location from 20kΩ to 100KΩ and higher, on IT AC/DC systems (depending on system capacitance).
The Network Rail certified Tier 3 system provides overall IR measurements, as well as feeder level fault location.
Tier 3 uses Bender’s patented AMP technology and current measurement type-A CTs (current transformers) for fault location. AMP is based on a special clocked measuring voltage controlled by a micro-controller and adapts automatically to prevailing system conditions. Software-based evaluation means system leakage currents causing interference on evaluation circuits can be differentiated from the measured variable proportionate to the insulation resistance in ohms.
RS4 Tier 2
RS4 Tier 2 enables complex individual feeder measurements and delivers enhanced monitoring and measurement capabilities over the RS4 Tier 3. This compliant solution offers increased system availability by providing the full insulation resistance (IR) levels of individual feeders, in addition to overall system level IR.
Tier 2 compliance is achieved by the use of additional system components. These include Bender Type B current transformers (CTs), the EDS440WNR evaluator, Bender COM465IP condition monitors to enable complex individual feeder measurements. Comprehensive data readings and information on cable health enables operators to have a clearer overall assessment of the condition of the rail signal power system.
RS4 Tier 2 delivers the same functionalities as the Tier 1 solution at PSP level and is fully upgradable to deliver a Tier 1 solution with the addition of an EDS440WNR fault evaluator and Type B CT at FSP (Functional Supply Point) level.
RS4 Tier 1
RS4 Tier 1 is the most advanced of Bender UK’s Rail Signalling Monitoring Systems. It delivers the highest level of granularity of a monitored signalling power system and offers insulation resistance measurement to cable subsection level and FSP levels, in addition to all the advantages of the Tier2 system.
Incorporating an earth fault evaluator (EDS440WNR) and Type B current transformers (CTs) inside FSPs, it evaluates and locates fault sources and provides full insulation resistance measurement of the system and individual feeders, monitoring individual subsections of cable and FSP.
Tier 1 allows for the overall and individual feeder IR measurement using the Class II compliant field/FSP equipment to provide IR readings of each cable sub section. Tier 1 eliminates the need for earth connection, with all trackside equipment fully integrated into existing FSP enclosures. Importantly, it is able to measure the IR within the FSP switchgear where most faults occur.
Available in 650v mains or 110v supply option, Tier 1 is retrofittable to Class II and Class 1 equipment, while data and communications options can be customised to suit specific projects and customer requirements.
This article and any opinions it may contain are for informational and educational purposes only. Bender has made every reasonable effort to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information provided on this website. However, the information is presented “as is” without warranty of any kind. Bender does not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained and/or opinions presented in articles or posts on this website. No warranties, promises, and/or representations, expressed or implied, are given as to the nature, standard, accuracy or otherwise of the information provided in this website, nor to the applicability, suitability, or otherwise of the information to your particular circumstances.
By Mumtaz Farooqi MSc (Electrical, Electronics and Communications Engineering) Technical Manager, Bender UK